Compare free team size, paid seat rules and the activity records you actually need.
THE ATN TAKE · EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT
Clockify offers a five-user free timekeeping start, with local recall and paid monitoring as distinct features. Hubstaff has separate solo, seat-based and flat-package options. Choose the necessary project records and access controls before paying for or enabling activity capture. [5][6][4]
ClockifyTimers, manual entries, projects and reports. Optional monitoring is a separate feature. [1][2]
HubstaffProject time tracking with configurable activity records, reporting and role-based visibility. [3][4]
Free starting point
ClockifyFree for up to five users, including the owner, with unlimited time tracking. The seven-day Pro trial needs no card. [5]
HubstaffLimited ongoing free plan for one person; separate 14-day trial without a credit card. [6][7]
Entry paid plan
ClockifyBasic: US$4.99/seat monthly or US$3.99/seat/month prepaid annually (US$47.88/year), before tax. Monitoring requires Pro or above. [8][9]
HubstaffSupport lists Small Business Essentials at $144 annually for exactly three paid seats plus a free owner. Currency remains unconfirmed; no monthly term or add-ons. Confirm availability and included features. [6]
Projects and tasks
ClockifyOrganize records by projects and tasks. Basic includes report exports as PDF, CSV or Excel; administration and reporting features vary by tier. [1][8]
HubstaffAssign projects and to-dos/tasks to members; client links and further controls depend on the selected plan. [3]
Activity recording
ClockifyAuto Tracker keeps raw activity local. Separate Pro+ Activity Monitoring exposes app/site activity and optional screenshots to admins and permitted team managers. Default screenshot blur can be disabled; server screenshots last 60 days. [10][9][11]
HubstaffOptional screenshots and app/URL records depend on plan and organization settings. Provider says it does not log keystrokes; visible screen content can still enter screenshots. [4]
Paid billing unit
ClockifyPaid seats include active and invited users, owners and admins. Reduce subscriptions separately when needed; cancellation stops renewal at term end. Standard fees are nonrefundable, subject to stated exceptions. [5][12]
HubstaffOrdinary per-seat plans require two paid seats and count owners, managers and inactive members; Project Viewers are exempt. Removed seats stay available through the term without a partial refund. Essentials follows separate flat-plan rules. [6][13][14]
What to confirm
ClockifyThe monitoring FAQ currently offers no manual agent pause while the device is active. Set a necessary collection scope and inform participants; blur is not a confidentiality guarantee. CAKE.com restricts objectionable user content; adult-business eligibility is unverified. Collection-start wording differs across help pages; general activity retention remains unclear. [2][9][12][15][16]
HubstaffNo automatic sensitive-content blocking. Set screenshot blurring/disabling and role access deliberately; retention depends on data type and plan, and export permissions are limited. Official Free screenshot-retention statements conflict; Essentials is absent from the plan table. [4][17][18]
Affiliate status
ClockifyCAKE.com advertises 30% of qualifying new-customer revenue for up to one year, subject to approval and promotional restrictions. ATN enrollment and publisher suitability are unverified. [19][20][21]
HubstaffTerms list 20% on ordinary plans or 30% on Enterprise for 12 months, with an initial three-month hold. A qualifying referral must be a new U.S. company and add an employee within 30 days. ATN acceptance is unverified. [22]
Consider it forATN assessment
ClockifyA small team starting with project time records, choosing any monitoring separately after checking participant visibility and controls. [5][1][9]
HubstaffA team needing shared activity detail and able to govern capture, access and retention. The customer must establish a valid legal basis and meet applicable obligations; agreement alone is not a compliance finding. [14][4]
For authorized, non-graphic project and business records. This compares documented plans and controls, without timer-accuracy, monitoring or privacy tests. Toggl Track is separate from the newer Toggl app. A personal timeline, shared timesheet and administrator monitoring system have different access rules. Confirm lawful authority, participant notice, currency, taxes and the actual account configuration; adult-business eligibility is unverified.
Clockify’s ongoing Free plan covers five users including its owner. Hubstaff’s free option is a limited solo plan, while its ordinary paid plans have distinct seat rules and minimums. Owners, invitations and administrative roles can affect the bill even when they never run a timer. [5][6]
Separate timekeeping from monitoring
Clockify’s local Auto Tracker is not its Pro+ Activity Monitoring service. The latter can share app/site activity and screenshots with administrators and permitted team managers. Hubstaff also provides configurable team capture. Select the required records first; a local feature cannot establish privacy for the entire product. [10][9][4]
Do not treat blur as sensitive-content detection
Clockify’s screenshot blur defaults on but can be disabled. Hubstaff says it does not automatically identify and exclude sensitive screenshot content. Check what can appear on screen, who may view it and whether capture is necessary; a blurred preview is not a general confidentiality guarantee. [9][4]
Check pause and retention boundaries
Clockify’s current monitoring FAQ does not offer a manual agent pause while the device is active; its screenshot documentation specifies 60-day storage. Those rules differ from local Auto Tracker and from ordinary account retention. Neither tool’s activity volume establishes the quality of someone’s work. [2][11][15][4]
Compare like packages
Clockify Basic and its higher monitoring tier are different purchases. Hubstaff’s flat annual Essentials package is also distinct from ordinary per-seat plans, with its own limits. Compare the selected package, team size and export requirements; do not combine a low entry price with features from a higher tier. [8][9][6]
Export before closing a paid organization
Hubstaff cancellation is available through the organization page or support. Its linked refund policy limits the 30-day request to first-time customers and their first paid organization, with the organization archived or on Free. Screenshot downloads are limited to paid-account owners/managers and at most 30 days per export; trial and Free organizations cannot use that download function. [14][13][18]
Research based · No hands-on testing or numeric scores · Direct links, no affiliate tracking. Our editorial standards