A lasting Free tier versus a subscription-first service, with distinct sharing, recovery and export tradeoffs.
THE ATN TAKE · EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT
Proton Pass offers ongoing free personal use; 1Password offers a 14-day trial before a subscription. Compare their sharing model and recovery process before focusing on similar-looking annual price figures. Proton’s retrieved dollar currency is unconfirmed, and 1Password’s first-year direct-web promotion differs from its regular rate. No security winner follows from these product pages. [4][5][2][6]
Proton PassAn account-based vault for passwords and passkeys; Proton documents end-to-end encryption of vault contents. [1]
1PasswordA personal subscription vault with apps, browser extensions and item sharing. [2][3]
Starting option
Proton PassFree: unlimited logins and devices, ten email aliases, two vaults and vault sharing with two others; no card required. [4]
1Password14-day trial without a credit card. No ongoing free personal plan was established. [2]
Paid upgrade
Proton PassYearly Pass Plus is displayed at $35.88 per 12 months ($2.99/month equivalent). Renewal uses then-current pricing; confirm currency and tax. The initial 30-day refund requires cancellation and a request, with payment-method and reseller exceptions. [4][5]
1PasswordIndividual: US$2.99/month billed yearly for eligible new direct-web customers in year one (US$35.88 calculated). Regular annual pricing is US$3.99/month (US$47.88 calculated), before tax; future rates can change. Paid fees are nonrefundable; a frozen account permits viewing/exporting existing items but stops editing and browser autofill. [2][6][7][8]
Phone workflow
Proton PassAndroid and iOS apps; the documented export workflow requires a supported extension, web app or Windows app. [4][9]
1PasswordiOS and Android apps are included in the subscription. [3]
Across devices
Proton PassAutomatic account sync across supported desktop, mobile, web and browser apps. Free includes limited shared vaults; individual-item links and expanded sharing are paid features. [4]
1PasswordUse the personal subscription across your devices. Individual-item links share expiring copies rather than a continuously updated shared vault. [2][10]
What to consider
Proton PassPrepare encrypted-data recovery before a reset. Alias addresses remain readable for forwarding even though vault contents are encrypted. Supported non-mobile clients offer encrypted JSON ZIP or readable ZIP/CSV export; transfer fidelity was not tested. [11][12][9]
1PasswordKeep the account password, Secret Key and recovery arrangements accessible. A preconfigured recovery code also needs access to your account email. Desktop export files are unencrypted. Encrypted vault contents are distinct from service, diagnostic and contact data. [13][14][15][16]
Consider it forATN assessment
Proton PassIndividuals wanting a separate cross-platform vault with email aliases and limited free sharing. Its affiliate program prohibits promotion on adult sites; no ATN participation or tracking link is established. This is a publisher restriction, not a customer-use finding. [4][17][18]
1PasswordA personal subscription with item-link sharing and a deliberate recovery routine. Its public affiliate program requires CJ approval; ATN participation and publisher eligibility are unverified. [10][14][19]
Personal password-manager workflows; original KeePass 2.x only. Provider documentation is separate from editorial fit. We have not tested autofill, recovery, exports or resistance to compromise, or assessed independent audit reports. Family and business plans have separate terms.
Proton Free includes unlimited logins and devices with limited aliases and sharing. 1Password’s no-card trial is time-limited; its first-year annual promotion is for eligible new direct-web customers. Compare ongoing cost and the required feature, including local tax and future renewal, rather than treating both displayed monthly equivalents as the same offer. [4][5][2][6]
Choose vault sharing or an item handoff
Proton Free includes limited shared vaults, while its individual-item links require a paid plan. 1Password item links send expiring copies and can restrict access by email; later changes require a new link. Decide whether recipients need continued shared access or a bounded handoff. Personal plans do not establish business-team licensing. [4][10][3]
Make recovery independent of the account
Proton’s prepared phrase can recover both account access and encrypted data. A prepared 1Password recovery code uses the account email and issues replacement account credentials; the Secret Key itself is not a recovery code. Keep these materials outside the vault and preserve the verification channel. [11][14][13]
Verify the exit and privacy boundaries
Proton documents encrypted JSON ZIP or readable exports on supported non-mobile clients. 1Password desktop exports are readable, and mobile passkey transfer is a separate supported workflow. Proton’s forwarding aliases and both services’ account metadata sit outside a blanket claim that everything is inaccessible to the provider. No export or cryptographic audit was performed. [9][15][12][16]
Research based · No hands-on testing or numeric scores · Direct links, no affiliate tracking. Our editorial standards