Compare similar first-year prices, different renewals, announced changes and refund consequences.
THE ATN TAKE · EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT
Gandi and Porkbun have close current .com registration amounts, but Porkbun’s US$11.08 one-year renewal is below Gandi’s US$38.38 U.S. quote. Porkbun has announced a future increase, which remains an estimate. Assess the recurring term, DNS and mail dependencies instead of extending either initial price indefinitely. [1][3][6][12][4]
GandiDomain registration with LiveDNS and DNSSEC listed among included services; separate hosting and email products need their own review. [1][2]
PorkbunDomain registration with optional DNS; hosting and email are separate services. [3][4][5]
.com · first year
GandiUS$11.00 for one standard non-premium .com year in the U.S. view, before applicable tax. [1]
PorkbunUS$11.08 for one standard non-premium .com year, including ICANN and other domain fees. [3]
.com · one-year renewal
GandiUS$38.38 for a standard one-year renewal. US$34.54/year promotional renewal requires a 2–9-year term; tax and checkout conditions apply. [1]
PorkbunUS$11.08 for one .com renewal year. Provider projects approximately US$11.81 from November 1, 2026 at 04:00 UTC; that is a future estimate, not today’s quote. [3][6]
DNS and nameserver choice
GandiLiveDNS or external nameservers. Switching away deactivates optional Premium DNS; prepare existing website and email records first. [7]
PorkbunChoose Porkbun or external nameservers. Prepare website and email records before changing DNS. [4]
Registration-data privacy
GandiFree default redaction with extension exceptions. State, country, anonymized email and applicable company name may remain visible; the registrar retains underlying data. [8][2]
PorkbunFree default proxy privacy on eligible extensions; redaction is a different setting. Registrant data remains with the provider and lawful disclosure exceptions apply. [9][10][11]
Transfer and exit conditions
GandiUS$11.00 listed for .com transfer-in, generally adding a year. Transfer-out uses unlock/auth code and registry rules. Review associated mail dependencies and export needed mail before leaving. [1][12][13]
PorkbunUS$11.08 listed for .com transfer-in. Transfer-out requires unlock/auth code and applicable recent-registration or transfer locks; a hosting move alone need not move the registrar. [3][14][15]
Renewal and refund rules
GandiOptional auto-renew can begin about a month before the applicable cutoff and follows the prior manual term. Once launched, Gandi says it cannot be cancelled/refunded; registry rules limit other refunds. [16][2]
PorkbunNew registrations default to auto-renew. Eligible 96-hour refunds deduct 5% and delete the domain, including for renewal refunds. Disabling domain renewal does not cancel separate hosting/email. [5][17]
Registrar-use conditions
GandiDomain-specific and general terms require accurate registrant information and lawful, rights-respecting use. Registration does not establish case-specific adult-business or hosting approval. [18][2][13]
PorkbunRegistrar and registry rules require accurate ownership information and lawful, non-abusive use. No specific adult-business or hosting approval was established. [15]
Affiliate status
GandiCustomer referrals generally reward a US$5 discount code after a qualifying friend’s first order of at least US$3; the third reward differs. This is not a verified cash-affiliate program or ATN tracking link. [19]
PorkbunThe official affiliate page says the program is discontinued. Historical agreement pages do not establish a currently open program. [20]
Decision pointATN assessment
GandiIncluded DNS services that justify the recurring bill for the actual domain; compare the same renewal term and check attached mail before transferring away. [1][7][12]
PorkbunExternal DNS choice with a readable current renewal quote; budget the announced increase and check refund consequences before purchasing. [3][6][4][17]
Standard non-premium .com registration for non-graphic business and editorial sites. Prices are dated provider snapshots; currency, taxes, renewal term and promotional conditions remain explicit. Domain registration, DNS, hosting and affiliate admission are separate decisions. No support, reliability, security or recovery outcomes were independently tested.
Keep today’s quote separate from the announced increase
Porkbun’s checked table lists US$11.08 with domain fees included; its announcement projects approximately US$11.81 from November 1, 2026 at 04:00 UTC. Gandi lists US$38.38 for one renewal year and a different multi-year promotion. The future Porkbun estimate is not an already effective price. [3][6][1]
Distinguish stopping renewal from deleting the domain
Porkbun’s eligible 96-hour refund route deducts 5% and deletes the domain, including for renewal refunds. Gandi says a launched automatic renewal cannot be cancelled/refunded. Review the schedule before billing; neither process is an uncomplicated way to restore the old expiry date. [17][5][16]
Keep domain, DNS and email subscriptions separate
Both permit external nameservers, with DNS records prepared in advance. Gandi warns of associated mail consequences when transferring away; Porkbun says disabling domain auto-renew does not cancel hosting or email. Inventory the services actually attached to the address before changing the registrar or its renewal setting. [7][12][4][5]
Compare proxy privacy with redaction
Porkbun’s default proxy setting and optional redaction are different: supported proxy privacy substitutes service details, while redaction can leave real data at the registry. Gandi uses redaction with specified public fields and extension exceptions. Neither prevents every permitted disclosure or supplies anonymous ownership. [10][9][11][8][2]
Check transfer eligibility before planning a date
Both use registrar/registry transfer rules with recent-registration and recent-transfer restrictions. Unlock and authorization-code steps do not override a hold or dispute. A website host can often be changed through DNS without moving registration; keep those operations separate. [14][15][12][13][7]
Keep rewards outside the registrar judgment
Porkbun’s public affiliate program is explicitly discontinued. Gandi’s verified customer reward is a conditional discount coupon, not a public cash-commission quote. No ATN enrollment or case-specific business approval is established, and those program differences do not measure support or recovery quality. [20][15][19][18][2]
Research based · No hands-on testing or numeric scores · Direct links, no affiliate tracking. Our editorial standards