Compare payout eligibility, chargeback exceptions, collaborator records and account-exit limits.
THE ATN TAKE · EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT
Both publish an 80% standard creator share, but that percentage does not establish final bank proceeds. Fansly lists a US$20 USD ACH minimum with a rolling seven-day hold; LoyalFans advertises US$50 and two monthly periods, qualified by account and country terms. Match the available payout route and business obligations without treating a lower threshold as proof of faster or more reliable earnings. [1][8][12][3][4][11][5]
Fansly80% of subscription, sold-media, message and tip revenue. Refund or chargeback adjustments and receiving-bank or currency-conversion costs can reduce the amount ultimately retained. [1][2][3]
LoyalFans80% of fan payments excluding their tax component; 20% platform fee. This is before applicable payout-provider, conversion or transaction charges and adjustments. [4][5]
Documented earning tools
FanslySubscriptions, individual paid items, paid messages and tips. Permission tools also document locked text and live-event tickets. [1][6]
LoyalFansSubscriptions, separate video/audio stores, messages, live streaming and one-to-one calls are documented. [7]
U.S. bank payout minimum
FanslyUS$20 for USD ACH in the published method table. Country, account verification and the method offered in the account determine access; other methods or a displayed account minimum can differ. [8][9][10]
LoyalFansUS$50 is publicly advertised and ACH is listed. General terms make the applicable threshold, methods and fees depend on country and the account’s selected method. [11][5]
Payout timing and eligibility
FanslyA rolling seven-day hold applies to each transaction, followed by payout request review and method-dependent delivery. Published processing estimates are not a guaranteed payment date. [12]
LoyalFansTwo periods monthly: days 1–15 and 16–month end, with payment within seven working days after each period. Method, eligibility and withholding conditions still apply. [11][5][4]
Privacy and visibility limits
FanslyTimeline and location controls are documented, but a locked feed can leave profile details public. Deleting sold media or the account generally does not revoke access to previously purchased media. [13][6][14]
LoyalFansCountry/state blocking is documented but not guaranteed effective. Creators retain ownership while granting distribution and promotional permissions; deletion does not establish complete erasure. [15][5][4][16]
Identity and collaborator obligations
FanslyCreators must be 18+ and legally adult locally, pass identity checks and complete required tax documentation before withdrawing. Collaborators need approved identity and consent records; tags alone are not a substitute. Country and payout eligibility still require account-specific confirmation. [1][17][9][18]
LoyalFansIndividuals must be 18 or the higher local age of majority and legally eligible; qualifying entities are also covered. Government ID, tax documentation and collaborator age/identity verification plus written consent are required. [4][5]
Adjustments and additional costs
FanslyMost chargebacks are described as protected, with stated exceptions. Refunds or exceptional chargebacks can reduce earnings; banks and payout providers can add costs. A US$5 monthly wallet charge can begin after 12 months of inactivity and does not charge a saved card. [2][3][19]
LoyalFansRefunds/chargebacks can reduce earnings without reducing the platform fee. General terms exempt unauthorized-payment fraud or platform errors and allow deduction disputes within 30 days; the supplement uses broader language. [4][5]
Account exit and records
FanslyPurchased-media access can persist after account deletion. An earnings/payout history view is documented, but a complete archive/export process and current retention exceptions were not fully verified; preserve needed business records before closing an account. [6][10]
LoyalFansClosure waits for active subscriptions to expire. Below-minimum balances are conditional and may be forfeited. The supplement gives up to 45 days after termination for undisputed earnings, subject to holds/setoff. Post-deletion access clauses differ. [5][4]
Creator referral program
FanslyCreator referral: 5% of referred sales for one year, then 1.5%; referral must precede completion of the creator application. A separate fan-referral reward exists. Cookie duration, referral minimum and ATN eligibility remain unverified. [20]
LoyalFansTerms use 5% of referred-creator Fan Payments; the payout page instead uses Creator Earnings. Same-session signup and cookies are required. The calculation conflict and ATN eligibility remain unresolved. [21][11]
Decision pointATN assessment
FanslyAn eligible creator whose available U.S. ACH route suits the US$20 threshold and seven-day hold, and who can maintain collaborator records and plan around retained purchaser access. This is a workflow judgment, not an earnings or payout-reliability rating. [8][12][17][6]
LoyalFansDocumented stores and calls alongside twice-monthly payout periods, where identity, recordkeeping and account-specific payout requirements suit the business. [7][11][4]
For consenting adult creators who meet local age, identity, tax and platform requirements. Published U.S. USD payout examples depend on available methods and account eligibility. Revenue share is not final bank proceeds. Company documentation does not establish earnings potential, payout reliability or tested privacy performance. Inaccessible legal clauses and conflicting terms remain explicit.
Fansly applies a rolling seven-day hold to each transaction before payout review and method-dependent delivery. LoyalFans uses two monthly periods, with payment within seven working days after each period when eligible. Its terms defer applicable minimums and fees to country/method settings. Neither published threshold guarantees an immediate deposit. [8][12][9][11][5]
Model costs and disputed transactions separately
Fansly describes protection from most chargebacks with exceptions and separately documents receiving-bank and conversion costs. LoyalFans permits deductions, while its general terms add specified unauthorized-payment fraud/platform-error exceptions and a 30-day deduction-dispute route. Do not assume every dispute is protected or every 80% share reaches the bank unchanged. [2][3][4][5]
Keep collaborator identity and consent records
Fansly’s newer Co-Performers workflow supports on-site requests, external verification invitations and manual review. Transitional tags do not replace retained consent records. LoyalFans also requires identity/age and written consent documentation; it pays the uploading account, which remains responsible for any private revenue-sharing arrangement. Neither tagging nor appearing together creates an automatic split. [17][18][4]
Separate visibility settings from ownership and permissions
Fansly’s feed/location controls have different scopes and a locked feed can leave profile details public. LoyalFans documents country/state blocking but disclaims guaranteed effectiveness. Retained creator ownership does not remove platform distribution/promotional permissions, and no control was independently tested as anonymity or leak prevention. [13][6][15][5][4][16]
Check what closing the account actually changes
Fansly help says purchased access can persist after deletion; complete current legal retention and export details were not accessible. LoyalFans waits for active subscriptions to expire and qualifies below-minimum final balances, while its general and supplemental clauses differ on purchaser access after deletion. Preserve authorized originals and business records; neither closure establishes erasure of every copy or licence. [6][14][10][5][4][16]
Plan for an inactive balance
Fansly documents a US$5 monthly wallet-funded charge after 12 months of inactivity, using spending balance before creator earnings and stopping when the balance is exhausted or activity resumes. LoyalFans has distinct final-balance and payment-information conditions. Resolve the applicable payout route before leaving funds unattended; do not transfer one platform’s inactivity rule to the other. [19][9][5][4]
Keep referral calculations outside the seller share
Fansly’s creator-referral schedule changes after the first year and has separate account/application conditions. LoyalFans’ legal referral terms use Fan Payments, while its payout page uses Creator Earnings as the base. That difference remains unresolved; neither published program establishes ATN enrollment or a personal tracking link. [20][21][11]
Research based · No hands-on testing or numeric scores · Direct links, no affiliate tracking. Our editorial standards